http://hindtoday.com/Blogs/ViewBlogsV2.aspx?HTAdvtId=8023&HTAdvtPlaceCode=IND 
Manoj Padhi |
| Blog | Posted By: manojpadhi on:6/7/2011 12:59:31 AM |
|
|
|  |  |
| There is no magic wand to fight corruption Marks awarded = 0/100
| There are plenty of ways by which we can fight corruption. Marks awarded = 100/100
|
Qualification: Professor Economics, PHD 8th Pass, Yoga Guru
Inspired by Baba Ramdev's Hindi definition of corrupt – gaddar, I have been scolding such people since a while. When I designated our Prime Minister as Gaddar, many disliked that label. I 100% agree with Baba Ramdev's Hindi definition of corrupt.
After reading this, you may click any of the buttons above:
- I agree ( that Dr. Manmohan Singh is a Gaddar PM )
- I disagree
- Can't say.
Per dictionary.com definition – the adjective corrupt is described as - guilty of dishonest practices, as bribery; lacking integrity; crooked.
So, when Manmohan Singh claims to be honest – his actions are not honest – as we will elaborate with examples – he lacks integrity and guilty of dishonest.
Dictionary.com describes the adjective honest as:
Honorable in principles, intentions, and actions; upright and fair: an honest person.
showing uprightness and fairness: honest dealings. gained or obtained fairly: honest wealth. be right per dictionary definition of honest
While I agree with almost 100% what Baba Ramdev says about corruption - Baba Ramdev and I differ only in case of Dr. Manmohan Singh – Baba says – "Manmohan Singh is politically dishonest; The PM as a person is honest but questions are arising on his honesty as a politician"
I say – Manmohan Singh is 3-in-1 - "dishonest" , "corrupt" and "gaddar (traitor)" as not only he fits in to the above definition of honest but his character also overlaps with the definition of "corrupt" and "traitor".
Now, let us examine the definition of "traitor" (noun) – gaddar.
Dictionary.com describes the word traitor as
"1. a person who betrays another, a cause, or any trust.
2. a person who commits treason by betraying his or her country.
Let us integrate the above 3 definitions and try to correlate to see whether his actions are merely "talk the talk" or he is a "walk the talk" person using his record of the past 7+ years as PM.
Here is what I inferred and I would provide reasoning for each of my charge.
Dr. Manmohan Singh is guilty of
- guilty of dishonest practices –( see definition of corrupt)
- zero uprightness and zero fairness (see definition of honest )
- Betraying a cause and trust. (see definition of traitor)
Let us elaborate his actions.
| Charge -1 : Betraying a cause |
| He says | He ignores | He does |
- there was no magic wand to end corruption
- The government is serious and we are concerned about corruption and black money. There is no doubt. But there is no magic wand
| [Note that our serious Dr. Manmohan Singh wouldn't look in to this window – why?] [Note that our serious Dr. Manmohan Singh was not part of that battle – why?] | Doesn't sign the UN anti-corruption treaty since 2005. His negotiator Kapil Sibbal tells Baba Ramdev – "find out the names and Bank account details of all the people, who stashed money abroad" - When Baba Ramdev asked – he unleashes CBI and ED to audit his companies.
- Promises a committee
- Wouldn't televise live the Lokpal bill discussion of Anna Hazare and team, which is very common in Unites States using C-SPAN. http://cspan.org/ ]
|
| Conclusion: Deterrent and Transparency are the real magic wands, which Dr. Singh says "not". If Ramalinga Raju, Raja and Kanimozhi were knowing about a potential 150 years of punishment – they wouldn't have dared to risk their life in jail. Now, they are most likely to get 5 to 7 years in jail and would get a waiver of the time spent in jail before their conviction i.e. during the trial. They were allowed to eat home foods – Idly, Vada – special treatment for VVIP Chors. |
| Charge -2 : Betraying trust , zero uprightness |
| He says | He ignores | He does |
- Would n't hesitate to appear before PAC
- Was not aware of that CVC was corrupt
| - JPC and wasted a parliament session
- Dr. Subramanian Swamy and Mr. Arun Shourie's early warning and allows the scam happen under his nose – knowing that CAG can catch that only at the end of the yearly audit. Would he do the same, if he were told that his home is being burgled by Raja, who took all his cash and all the gold ornaments of his wife are looted by Kanimozhi? He would jumped from his chair and instructed CBI to rush to his home.
- Would appoint tainted CVC P.J.Thomas to cover up 2G scam in spite of warning by leader of opposition Ms. Sushma Swaraj.
- The President of India is already a puppet. A non-puppet president Dr. Kalam was kicked out after one term because, he ruined Ms. Sonia Gandhi's PM aspirations.
- CBI was used to blackmail Ms. Mayawati to muster numbers during Presidential election
- The President Pratibha Patil was also tainted in a rural bank scam and yet got elected.
- Mr. L.K.Advani alleged that the puppet President accepts a memorandum and does nothing. The President's office clarified that she does send it to PM/Cabinet – but forgot to mention whether she ever follows up and informs the people the status of their memorandum?
- CBI gives Lalu Yadav a reprieve in Corruption Case
- Lalu Yadav has been returning the favor by scolding Baba Ramdev.
- Mayawati and Mulayam were repeatedly blackmailed by CBI and forced to support the minority Government of Dr. Manmohan Singh.
| - Blackmails Mulayam Singh using CBI and gets number at PAC.
- Dr. M.M.Joshi's PAC report was designated as "scrap" and politically motivates.
- They avoided a debate on PAC report.
- Note, if there were No JPC and Supreme court probe - there would not be any 2G scam courtesy the Zero Loss (Kapil Sibbal) argument of Kapil Sibbal
- He asked his minister to take the blame for Thomas recruitment.
|
| Conclusion: CBI was misused by PM , who also closed his eyes during huge scams; ignored major warnings. Avoided JPC probe and wasted a whole parliament session before succumbing to demand of opposition. He doesn't want to come under jurisdiction of Lokpal, in spite of independent charge of several ministries. |
| Charge -3 : Zero fairness |
| He says | He allows | He does |
- Recall during Anna Hazare's fast two months before– there were no precedence of including Civil society in drafting any Bill
| - Binayak Sen, Arudhanti Roy, John Dayal, Sabnam Hasmi, Kashmir separatists are welcome to talk separation of Kashmir from India. / Naxlite are victims argument.
- In a recent artcle dated 29-May-2011, titled "Pre-emptive Sangh offensive on the Bill to prevent communal violence" , activist Dr. John Dayal reveals that - several liberal eminent bigoted activists were invited by Ms. Sonia Gandhi since 1.5 years to append sections, in the proposed "Communal Violence Bill" that would put Hindus at disadvantage, just like the Dowry act put many Husbands at disadvantage.
This engagement did bear fruit. The National Advisory Council headed by United Progressive Alliance chairperson Mrs Sonia Gandhi set up a working group coordinated by two NAC members, journalist-activist Farah Naqvi and former bureaucrat and NGO activist Harsh Mander – with members from the various religious communities. The three members from the Christian community included this writer, together with two lawyers, Sister Mary Scaria and P I Jose of Delhi. Major activist-members included Shabnam Hashmi of Anhad, Teesta Setalvad of Mumbai and Vrinda Grover and Usha Ramanathan, and both jurists, from Delhi. After sittings lasting more than a year and a half, the working group, finally assisted by Additional Solicitor General Indira Jaisingh, came up with a draft law, and called the Prevention of Communal and Targeted Violence (Access to Justice and Reparations) Bill, 2011. The Bill has been put on the NAC website and people's reactions have been sought with a deadline of 10th June 2011. The draft will then be sent to the government to undergo the processes which will finally see it being presented in either House of Parliament, presumably later this year in the Monsoon or winter sessions. This writer, and Ms Shabnam Hashmi and jurists Vrinda Grover and Usha Ramanathan have expressed their own reservations to the NAC about several aspects of the Bill, especially in areas of Centre-State relations, impunity, and trigger mechanisms to make operative central intervention, the powers and structures of the Central and State authorities sought to be created to oversee the control of violence and issues of reparation and so on and finally to ensure the empowerment of the victims and ending impunity. Several Muslim members have also wanted the draft law to be tweaked in several areas to meet the challenge of hate campaigns, violence, rehabilitation and reparations | - To draft the Anti-Corruption bill – Civil Society activists like Anna Hazare and his team are not welcome – PM said- No precedence.While Congress President has been involving bigoted activists to draft the communal violence bill since January 2010.
- Baba Ramdev was threatened, warned and discouraged from the airport – much before the June-4 satyagraha date. It was Baba's presence of mind and false promises that stumped those cunning and dishonest people like Kapil Sibbal.
- Our Chanakya baba Ramdev demonstrated – "Sathe Sathyem Samacharet" and in stead of surrendering to injustice, he had done a Shivaji Maharaj, a move unexpected by any one.
|
| Conclusion: So, when comes to convicted criminals like Binayak Sen and Separatists – they are welcome to draft bills. But when comes to Baba Ramdev – he was depicted as RSS agent, who are patriots and doesn't agree with the Congress definition of Secularism (appeasement of minorities – read the bill to know). When Anna Hazare want to be included in the draft of Lokpal bill – no precedence – while since Jan 2010, bigoted activists like John Dayal, Teesta Setalvad, Sabnam Hasmi have totally revised the communal violence bill to put Hindus in jail. Now, a Muslim terrorist don't have to become a suicide bomber; he just has to go to a Hindu area and start a squabble and when beaten up, lodge an FIR under the PREVENTION OF COMMUNAL AND TARGETED VIOLENCE (ACCESS TO JUSTICE AND REPARATIONS) BILL, 2011 Afzal Guru is not hanged since last 6 years because we have a puppet President and Gaddar PM. Period. |
Our egoist PM Dr. Manmohan Singh has beaten up sleeping people in Ramlila ground to satisfy his ego – "How dare Baba Ramdev flip-flop even though no timeline was provided for his demands?" (He thought Baba was stupid as unlike Anna Hazare he didn't demand a timeline in advance) - but wouldn't visit the hospital to see the victims– wouldn't introspect – pending the Baba-beat-up order, why he let Mr. Chidambaram go to Chennai to attend Narayan Murthy's son's wedding?
He had demonstrated such ego when Shri L.K.Advani labeled him as a "weak PM" during last Lok Sabha Elections. He wouldn't ready for a face-off election debate with Mr. Advani and yet claim that he is "strong".
He again demonstrated the same while replying to the 2G scam in Parliament. Blamed BJP regime for the scam and justified his inaction.
He is the only PM of India, who has been scolded by Supreme Court time and again and yet claims that he is "honest".
So, when people designate him personally honest and politically dishonest – I would not buy those arguments, because a man acts based on his "character", which is usually developed over the years based on one's upbringing, religious beliefs, ethics, and moral convictions. Former PM Vajpayee didn't succumb to Ms. Jayalalitha's blackmail (She requested misuse of CBI) and preferred to go to the people.
Now I rest my case and would like to ask you – "Do you agree with me that Dr. Manmohan Singh is a गद्दार PM (Traitor) ?.
--
View/Post profile at
http://hindtoday.com/bihar/HTMemberList.aspx To unsubscribe from this group, send email to BIHARTODAY-unsubscribe@googlegroups.com
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.com/group/BIHARTODAY?hl=en
